Friday, 5 October 2018

Is Good Economics Bad Politics!


Economics relates to allocation of resources to various segments of the economy. It can tell you the methodology or the means of allocation of resources for enhancing production, efficiency in distribution and equitable consumption. There is always a tradeoff between competing demands in any economy as the resources are limited. Good economics implies following such economic policies that pushes the ‘Production Possibility Curve’ outwards. Politics can broadly be understood as the means to the political power. Success in politics is achieved by taking steps that increases the possibility of winning elections.

Good Economics ensures larger benefits to the large population. And if political parties work towards the wellbeing of large sections of society winning elections thereby, it is good economics and good politics. The effective communication with the electorate about the outcome of economic decisions and level of awareness & education of the citizens, determine, whether good economics is good politics.

In a democracy, where demands are generated by different stakeholders, there is a political cost to every decision. Technocratic prescriptions can ignore the political economy but a politician will always keep an eye on the political consequences of any economic policy. 

Political cost to economic decisions can be reduced through better communication skills of leadership; successful leaders are generally good orators. Cost reduction can also be achieved by increased educational outreach and higher level of awareness amongst the electorate. The time frame for impact assessment of economic decision will also determine the correlation between the economic decision and its political cost. Because the result of some of the steps taken by the government might take years to be reflected in changed ground realities, but the elections have to be won every five years. In India the problem is further compounded by the fact that we have multiple elections at the Centre and the States.

At times, powerful interest groups with high stakes in maintaining status quo, exists within a Nation. Their own compulsions take precedence over economic decisions leading to bad politics. Sometimes divisive forces in a society raise their head and bog down the decision making process of the state, creating chaos. Existence of strong public institutions and pillars of democracy is a safeguard for decision-making process. The selection criterion for the right candidate by the electorate at the elections, influences the considerations for decisions of the political parties. In an ideal democracies good economics is always good politics, but rarely such situations exists, otherwise how you can explain farm loan waivers and subsidies instead of investing resources in infrastructure for better quality of life.

Mostly, the form of governance and prevalent political structure, determine, whether good economics is good politics. Nations should build sustainable institutions to; safeguard minority interest and maintaining balance of power between pillars of governance and holding free & fare elections. Countries spending on education, transparency, information sharing and disclosers establish a healthy and a vibrant political system. Then alone a positive relationship between good economics and good politics is sustained.   

By Political System we mean a system of government. Political System is a complex system of categories involving the question of who should have authority and ownership of resources and what the government’s influence on its people and economy should be? And Political Structure refers, to institutions or groups and their relations to each other, their pattern of interaction within political systems and to regulations, laws and the norms present.
Out Constitution specifically says that Political Democracy has no meaning till we achieve Economic Democracy. Economic Democracy means that the benefits of economic development reach to all the segments of society, across caste, religion and geography. This equity can only be achieved by good economics.

In a mature and just nation, Good Economics is Good Politics; Economic Democracy and Political Democracy coexist in an efficient governance model. If this healthy relationship is non-existent, then there is lot to be desired from the institutions, government, political parties and the citizens, all taken together.

Gopal Krishna Agarwal, National Spokesperson for Economic Affairs, BJP
Mobile:  9810019753

No comments:

Post a Comment